What is it like to engage in talks with Moscow's officials concerning the conflict in Ukraine?
This question has piqued widespread interest in the wake of multiple recent rounds of ceasefire talks, which have so far seemed to produce little progress four years since the comprehensive invasion.
Another round of US-mediated discussions is expected to occur in Geneva later this week. Ahead of it, a key participant of the Ukrainian leadership's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in recent military-to-military talks, has provided his viewpoint.
According to Kyslytsya, these dealings are professional and mostly free of the sort of political and rhetorical posturing observed in other forums by Russian leadership.
"The military possess a better understanding of the realities in the combat zone," he remarked in a conversation earlier this week.
"It's another thing whether they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of reporting [back] directly…without cooking or changing the facts," he added.
It is not an easy thing to try to halt a major conflict. The reality of the battlefield in eastern Ukraine - where thousands of drones patrol and strike over a vast so-called "contested area" separating the two sides, while 200,000 Ukrainian civilians still reside in the "fortress belt" urban areas of the Donbas - renders the practical process of separation extremely complicated.
"It is essential to establish a precise framework of guidelines and protocols," Kyslytsya said, "along with a method to confirm and monitor."
The Involvement of External Parties
A great deal of this work, he said, is finished, partly due to the close involvement of American officials, such as General Alexus Grynkewich and a high-ranking Army official.
It's obviously against Kyiv's interest to criticise representatives of the American administration, but when Kyslytsya compliments the American team for its work, he comes across as sincere.
"We must credit the US side for their commitment and their patience," he states, "because they sit in the meetings non-stop. They not only watch…they put inquiries and they heed our responses."
Kyslytsya was equally complimentary about the roles of the former president's adviser, whom he referred to as "experienced", and wealthy mediator Steve Witkoff, whom he characterized as "a much wiser person than the simplified portrayal often presented in the media".
The US, Kyslytsya said, will undertake a key role in monitoring any future ceasefire, with resources encompassing satellite and other types of high-tech surveillance.
"It is necessary to have an entity who will serve as adjudication, for the reason that if there is a breach there must be a third party that is reliable [and] authoritative."
Past and Current Oversight Challenges
During an eight-year period before the full-scale offensive in recent years, this monitoring role was played by the OSCE - a body whose restricted means and lack of punitive powers made it largely incapable of preventing an escalation.
"That was no small feat [for them] simply to operate a couple of drones flying above the area," Kyslytsya commented. "It's kind of the stone age era in contrast with what we have today."
In comparison, latest analyses indicate that as many as 12,000 drones are active above the urban center of Pokrovsk at any given moment.
A Personal Perspective on Confronting the Adversary
Inquired how he managed to negotiate directly from delegates representing a leader in the Kremlin who has been willing to sacrifice more than a million-plus of his own men to conquer Ukraine, Kyslytsya, also a former UN ambassador, provided his response.
He explained that he'd had a long time of experience.
"I saw far more difficult situations. I served five years in at the UN, a portion before the major war. I would sit in the room with the enemy on a regular basis."
One evening is seared in his memory: 23 February 2022.
In the middle of an urgent UN Security Council meeting, convened to discuss the looming threat in Ukraine, the ambassador received news that his country was being assaulted.
Simultaneously, far away to the east in Kyiv, initial far-off detonations were heard as the total attack on Ukraine began.
Amid moments of agonising tension, Kyslytsya tried to get his Russian counterpart, the Russian envoy, to contact his boss, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov, to obtain guarantees that Russian forces would not invade.
"I've already said everything that I am aware of now," the Russian diplomat replied, according to his Ukrainian colleague. "I'm not going to disturb the minister at this time."
Everyone's lives changed at that moment. The diplomat remained at the UN for another three years before returning to the Ukrainian capital.
The Path Forward
If the delegations reconvene in Geneva on Thursday, he'll be there, still thrashing out the details and logistics of a halt in fighting but anticipating continuously for the crucial element of the jigsaw to be resolved.
"Hostilities might be ended by simply one call of one person to his military chief of staff," he said.
"But apparently, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not up to stopping the war for the time being."